Plain Cheese
$3.75The classic. Tomato, mozzarella, a whisper of oregano.
Three generations, one 800° oven, and Mama’s Sunday sauce. Grab a slice on 5th Ave or get a whole pie to your door in Park Slope & Gowanus.
Call to order — pickup or delivery (718) 555-0195Birthdays, office lunches, PTA nights, stoop parties. We bring trays hot and on time — just give us 24 hours’ notice.
In 1995, Rosa Benedetto hauled a brick oven into a narrow storefront on 5th Avenue and started selling slices to everyone who walked by. Today her son Sal runs the oven and granddaughter Gina runs the counter — and Rosa still tastes the sauce every Sunday.
Same recipe, same oak wood, same “you look hungry, have another slice.”
“The Grandma square is the reason I haven’t moved out of Park Slope. Not kidding.”
“Ordered the Party Pie Pack for my son’s 10th. Showed up early, still bubbling. Kids lost their minds.”
“Rosa remembered my order after I’d been away for two years. That’s a neighbourhood spot.”
| Mon – Thu | 11am – 10pm |
| Fri – Sat | 11am – 12am |
| Sunday | 12pm – 10pm |
412 5th Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11215 · between 7th & 8th St
Send the date and headcount — Gina will call you back the same day with a tray plan and a price. For tonight’s dinner, just call.